Skip to main content

Squatters vs. Holdover Tenants: How Miami Landlords Can Deal With Either

Squatters vs. Holdover Tenants: How Miami Landlords Can Deal With Either

A lot of frustrating things happen when you’re a rental property owner, but many landlords would tell you that nothing is more stressful than dealing with someone living in a unit they have no right to occupy. Naturally, your first thought is to kick them out, but you need to know what kind of occupant you have.

In Florida, the law treats squatters and holdover tenants differently, which means your approach matters if you want an outcome in your favor. Guessing wrong can turn a quick fix into an expensive lawsuit.

Key Highlights

  • Classification comes first. A squatter never had permission to occupy the property. A holdover tenant entered lawfully and stayed past the lease. Each gets a different legal process.
  • Squatters can be removed through the sheriff. Under Florida Statute 82.036, owners or authorized agents can file a sworn affidavit with the Miami-Dade County Sheriff instead of starting a full eviction.
  • Holdover tenants require court action. Landlords must follow Chapter 83 by serving the proper notice, filing for eviction, and obtaining a Writ of Possession.
  • Misclassifying an occupant is risky. A false affidavit or a self-help eviction can lead to damages, penalties, and attorney’s fees.
  • Documentation and prevention protect you. Clear leases, organized records, and secured vacant units reduce both squatting and holdover problems.

Who Is Considered a Squatter?

A person is considered a squatter when they enter your property without permission and never had a lease, rental agreement, or other legal right to be there. Typical examples include people breaking into a vacant house or moving into an empty investment property and presenting a forged lease agreement.

Thanks to Section 82.036 of the Florida Statutes, removing unauthorized occupants has become easier since July 1, 2024. An owner or authorized agent can now sign a sworn affidavit and ask the Miami-Dade County Sheriff to remove the occupant without going through an entire eviction process. Naturally, the facts have to fit first. The affidavit should state that:

  1. You are the owner, or the owner’s authorized agent.
  2. The person entered without permission and was never a tenant.
  3. The occupant is not an owner, co-owner, or a person with a legal right to the property.
  4. No litigation is pending between you and the occupant over the property.
  5. The occupant is not on the lease, and the property is not subject to an active rental agreement.

In your affidavit, authorize the sheriff to enter, search, and remove the occupants using reasonably necessary force, since a 2025 amendment added this requirement. Once the sheriff verifies the information and serves notice, the occupant must leave. The sheriff may charge a fee, and local practices on fees and timing can vary, so call the Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office before filing.

Who Is Considered a Holdover Tenant?

A holdover tenant is different. This person has entered your property lawfully, and usually under a lease. They are now considered unauthorized occupants because the lease has expired or was terminated, but their prior permission means the sheriff’s affidavit process won’t apply. You will need to refer to Chapter 83 of Florida’s landlord-tenant law to resolve the issue.

Since you can’t opt for self-help evictions by locking them out or removing their personal belongings yourself, here’s what you should do:

  1. Check the lease type. If the lease had a fixed term and has ended, you may not need to provide notice before filing. If the tenancy is month-to-month, Florida law requires you to provide written notice at least 15 days before the lease expires.
  2. Serve the right notice based on the circumstances. For unpaid rent, a 3-day notice is sufficient. This gives the tenant a chance to pay or leave. For lease violations, you need to provide a 7-day notice, which may be a cure or unconditional notice, depending on the severity of the lease violation.
  3. File for eviction in Miami-Dade County Court if the tenant doesn’t comply.
  4. Obtain a judgment and Writ of Possession, which is crucial to finalize an eviction. The sheriff will then execute the order.

Why Misclassification Is Costly

Treating a holdover tenant like a squatter can be a huge risk. If you state in an affidavit that someone never had permission to be there, but they actually have a lease, an oral agreement, or a rent history, you could face liability.

The statute also protects tenants, and if you wrongfully remove them, you could end up paying damages, penalties, and attorney fees. Laws also prohibit self-help evictions, meaning you cannot skip the legal process to streamline the removal of an unauthorized occupant, so you need to be very careful how you resolve the matter.

Practical Steps For Removing an Unauthorized Occupant

  • Document Everything: Keep your deeds, leases, photos, rent transactions, and communications. When the sheriff reviews the affidavit, these documents will solidify your claims.
  • Don’t Confront the Occupant: No part of the process requires you to meet the occupant in person, much less confront them. This can put you at risk, and a heated exchange will only complicate matters. Contact law enforcement for a trespassing report if you believe someone has unlawfully entered.
  • Screen Carefully and Write Clear Leases: Many holdover problems start with vague lease terms. Spell out the end date, renewal rules, notice requirements, and consequences of staying past the term. Use comprehensive criteria when screening tenants.
  • Secure Vacant Properties: Squatters typically enter properties that aren't properly secured and look neglected. Regular inspections, working locks, utilities in your name, and visible signs of ownership reduce the chance of getting unauthorized occupants.

FAQs

  • A squatter entered without permission and never had a lease or rental agreement. A holdover tenant originally had permission, usually through a lease, and stayed after it expired or was terminated.
  • No. Even with a true squatter, you should use the sheriff’s removal process under Section 82.036 rather than changing locks or removing belongings yourself.
  • No. If the person ever had a lease, an oral agreement, or a rent history with you, the sheriff’s process generally does not apply, and you will need to use the court eviction process.

The Benefits of Hiring a Property Manager

Telling a squatter from a holdover tenant, serving the right notices, and keeping accurate records all take time and legal know-how, and one wrong step can be costly. Your best bet is to be proactive and avoid being in this situation in the first place.

With a company like Pristine Property Management, you won’t have to worry about these problems. We can help you draft a clear lease agreement, conduct regular inspections, and even handle evictions when needed. All you have to do is earn passive income.

Need help protecting your Miami rental?

Feel free to contact us, and we can discuss an arrangement that works for you!

Feel free to contact us

More Resources

back